Environment Agency climb down after Fish Legal pressure against the lowering of standards for sewage discharges
6th October 2021
After the threat of legal action from environmental angling organisation Fish legal, the Environment Agency (EA) has said that it will amend the Regulatory Position Statement (RPS) to make it clear that the EA is not allowing illegal discharges of sewage into rivers.
Fish Legal is a not-for-profit organisation of dedicated lawyers who use the law on behalf of anglers to fight polluters and others who damage and threaten the water environment.
Fish Legal wrote to the EA on 10 September demanding that they withdraw the RPS after the EA gave the green light to water companies to breach their environmental permits and discharge partially treated sewage into rivers due to Covid and Brexit-related chemical-shortages.
Now the EA say they will “amend” the RPS.
Despite this victory for rivers, Fish Legal is still concerned at the “risk assessments” conducted by the water companies for the sewage works discharging into rivers and streams. The risk assessments suggest that very little has been done to fully consider environmental impact, particularly in the so-called “low-risk” “category A” rivers. The EA imply in their response, for instance, that they may not allow the water companies to use the RPS for rivers with “good” or “high” environmental status. But where a river is already failing its environmental standards, it is more acceptable to let the incompletely treated effluent into the river.
It is a revelation that these rivers are considered to be less important and Fish Legal are encouraging its members to continue to take action if their river is being deprioritised for environmental protection. If anyone is concerned about any of their local rivers, they are urged to contact the water companies to find out what protections have been put in place to ensure that there is no pollution or environmental harm.
Risk Assessment Category A – Watercourse and WWTW site
These entries have been taken directly from the water company risk assessments and contain possible duplication and some blank columns, as in the originals sent to Fish Legal by the EA.
Severn Trent Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
Unnamed Trib of Chatcull Brook
ASHLEY (STW)
Unamed trib of Meece Brook
BALDWINS GATE (STW)
River Derwent
BELPER (STW)
Trib Of River Sence
BILLESDON (STW)
River Leadon
BOSBURY RBC (STW)
Trib Of Claverdon Brook
CLAVERDON (STW)
River Trent
CRANKLEY POINT (STW)
Derrington Brook
DERRINGTON (STW)
River Avon
EVESHAM (STW)
Langham Brook
LANGHAM (STW)
Trib Of River Dove
LONGNOR (STW) OLD
River Trent
MILTON (STW)
Norton Brook
NORTON JUXTA (STW)
River Trent
RUGELEY (STW)
Northumbrian Water – Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
Wansbeck from Font to Bothal Burn
MORPETH STW
Wear from Croxdale Beck to Lumley Park Burn
BARKERS HAUGH STW
Wear from Gaunless to Browney
BISHOP AUCKLAND (VINOVIUM) STW
Derwent
Lockhaugh STW
Wear DS of Lumley Park Burn to Tidal Limit
CHESTER LE STREET STW
Wear from Croxdale Beck to Lumley Park Burn
BELMONT STW
Wear from Gaunless to Browney
TUDHOE MILL STW
Beechburn Beck (Trib of Wear)
LOW WADSWORTH STW
Croxdale Beck from Source to Wear
BOWBURN STW
Gaunless from Source to Hummer Beck
BUTTERKNOWLE STW
Gaunless from Source to Hummer Beck
COCKFIELD STW
Leven from Source to Tame
GREAT AYTON STW
Gaunless from Source to Hummer Beck
RAMSHAW STW
South West Water Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
Bradninch
Cullompton
HICKS MILL STREAM
Gwennap (Lanner St Day)
Knowle
Lower River Yealm
Lee Mill
GWINDRA STREAM
North Fal (St Stephens Combe)
Sandford
Silverton
MOLE
South Molton
Upper River Fal
St Dennis
EXE
Tiverton
Uffculme
CULM
Willand
Southern Water Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
Swale
QUEENBOROUGH WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
SHOREHAM WTW
Arun
COLDWALTHAM WTW
Rother
LISS WTW
Brede
SEDLESCOMBE WTW
MARSH COURT
STOCKBRIDGE WTW
Broad Rife
SIDLESHAM WTW
Wingham
DAMBRIDGE WTW
Arun
SOUTH AMBERSHAM WTW
ROTHER
WAREHORNE WTW
Adur
STEYNING WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
BROOMFIELD BANK WTW
LANGSTONE HARBOUR
BUDDS FARM WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
EAST WORTHING WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
EASTBOURNE WTW
Thames
GRAVESEND WTW
Medway
HAM HILL WTW
Medway
MOTNEY HILL WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
NEWHAVEN WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
PEACEHAVEN WTW
SOLENT
PEEL COMMON WTW
ENGLISH CHANNEL
SANDOWN WTW
Adur
NEWBURY LANE CUCKFIELD WTW
Cockhaise Brook
PARK ROAD HANDCROSS WTW
Ouse
STAPLEFIELD WTW
Yorkshire Water Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
River Hull, River Hull Via Waterside pumping station
Beverley/STW
River Hull, River Hull Via Waterside pumping station
Beverley/STW
River Dearne
Bolton On Dearne/STW
River Aire
Castleford/STW
River Swale
COLBURN/STW
River Foss
Crayke/STW
River Foss
Crayke/STW
Pit Ings Stell (Trib Of River Swale)
DALTON ELDMIRE/STW
River Dearne
Darfield/No 2 STW
River Don
Denaby/NO 2 STW
River Aire
Dowley Gap/STW
North Sea (Via Sea Outfall)
FILEY/STW
North Sea (Via Sea Outfall)
FILEY/STW
North Sea And Hartendale Gutter
FLAMBOROUGH VILLAGE/STW
River Ouse (Blacktoft Channel – Tidal)(Estuary)
Gilberdyke/STW
River Ouse (Tidal)
Goole/STW
River Ouse (Tidal)
Goole/STW
Selby Dam
Hambleton/STW
Oak Beck
HARROGATE NORTH/STW
Crimple Beck Or River Crimple
HARROGATE SOUTH/STW
River Ouse (Tidal)
HEMINGBROUGH/NO 2 STW
North Sea
Hornsea/STW
River Ouse (Tidal)
Howden/STW
River Aire
Keighley Marley/STW
Lowthorpe Beck
Kilham/STW
River Derwent
Malton/STW
River Derwent
Malton/STW
River Ure
Masham/STW
River Ure
Masham/STW
River Ure
Masham/STW
Hoppelcarr Drain
Melbourne/STW
Tributary Of Winestead Drain
Patrington/STW
Costa Beck
Pickering/STW
River Ouse And Rawcliffe Ings Drain
RAWCLIFFE YORK/STW
River Ouse And Rawcliffe Ings Drain
RAWCLIFFE YORK/STW
Romanby/STW
Scalby Mills
North Sea (Via Long Sea Outfall)
SCARBOROUGH/STW
North Sea (Via Long Sea Outfall)
SCARBOROUGH/STW
River Ouse
SELBY/NO 2 STW
River Ouse
SELBY/NO 2 STW
Upper Fox Drain
Sherburn in Elmet/STW
Trib Of River Derwent
STAMFORD BRIDGE/NO 2 STW
Tadcaster/Trade STW
Tadcaster/Trade STW
Tadcaster/Trade STW
Tadcaster/Trade STW
Tadcaster/Trade STW
River Don (Tidal)
Thorne/STW
River Dearne
Wath on dearne/STW
Norton Beck
Wath Ripon/STW
Norton Beck
Wath Ripon/STW
River Don
Wharncliffe Side/STW
River Don
Wharncliffe Side/STW
North Sea (Via Sea Outfall)
Whitby/STW
North Sea (Via Sea Outfall)
Whitby/STW
Tributary of the River Rother
Woodall/STW
Mill Dyke
Adwick/No 2 STW
North Sea (Via Long Sea Outfall)
BRIDLINGTON/STW
North Sea (Via Long Sea Outfall)
BRIDLINGTON/STW
River Calder
CALDER VALE/STW
River Calder
CALDER VALE/STW
River Calder
CALDER VALE/STW
Humber Estuary
HULL/STW
Humber Estuary
HULL/STW
Humber Estuary
HULL/STW
Thames Water Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
River Kennet
BROAD HINTON
Froxfield Stream
Froxfield
Wessex Water Risk Assessment:
Receiving Watercourse
Site Name
Back Stream
Bishops Lydeard . Sewage Treatment Works
Bristol Avon (Semington Bk to By Bk)
Bradford-On-Avon . Sewage Treatment Works
Marden – conf Cowage Bk to conf R Avon (Brist)
Calne . Sewage Treatment Works
Somer
Chilcompton . Sewage Treatment Works
Avon (Brist) conf R Marden to conf Semington Bk
Chippenham Blackwell Hams Sewage Treatment Works
Bulkington Drove w/c source to conf Semington Bk
Erlestoke Erlestoke Park Sewage Treatment Works
Isle – Cad Bk to Fivehead River
Ilton Ashford Farm (Near) Sewage Treatment Works
Bristol Avon (By Bk to Netham Weir)
Keynsham . Sewage Treatment Works
Parrett – R Yeo to West Sedgemoor Drain
Langport Portfield Lane Sewage Treatment Works
Avon (Brist) conf R Marden to conf Semington Bk
Melksham . Sewage Treatment Works
Bristol Avon (By Bk to Netham Weir)
Saltford Mead Lane Sewage Treatment Works
Summerham Brook
Seend . Sewage Treatment Works
Yeo
Sherborne West Mill Lane Sewage Treatment Works
Sherston Avon
Sherston . Sewage Treatment Works
Stour (Middle u/s Pimperne Brook)
Sturminster Newton Opp Rixon Close Sewage Treatment Works
Avon (Brist) conf Tetbury Avon to conf R Marden
Sutton Benger . Sewage Treatment Works
Tetbury Avon – source to conf unnamed trib
Tetbury . Sewage Treatment Works
Bristol Avon (Semington Bk to By Bk)
Trowbridge Bradford Road Sewage Treatment Works
Not part of a river WB catchment
Watchet . Sewage Treatment Works
Tone – Wellington to Taunton
Wellington Tone Sewage Treatment Works
Keward Brook
Wells . Sewage Treatment Works
Not part of a river WB catchment
Weymouth . Sewage Treatment Works
Yeo Us Over Compton
Yeovil Sherborne Road (Pen Mill) Sewage Treatment Works